The Green Sheet Online Edition
April 23, 2012 • Issue 12:04:02
Gift card providers pull out of N.J.
As a consequence of a New Jersey law that allows the state to seize funds from unused gift cards, card brand American Express Co. removed all of its network-branded gift cards from the J-hooks and displays of retailers in the Garden State. In the wake of AmEx's action, prepaid card distributors InComm and Blackhawk Network announced plans to follow suit.
AmEx said it took the unprecedented step because it could not comply with the law's ZIP code collection mandate requiring retailers to collect the ZIP codes of customers who purchase AmEx-branded gift cards at the POS. In statements, InComm and Blackhawk echoed AmEx.
InComm said it would remove its own lines of open-loop, network-branded gift cards from over 2,500 New Jersey retail locations effective June 30, 2012. Blackhawk said it would pull its closed-loop, retailer-branded gift cards, representing more than 175 different brands, from over 1,300 stores in the state. But Blackhawk offered a caveat - that it would begin its June 2012 pullout unless the law was changed in the interim.
New Jersey is using the ZIP code collection requirement as a way to establish the basis for staking a claim to money that lies dormant on unused gift cards purchased within its borders. The requirement is part of New Jersey's unclaimed property law, which was updated in 2010 to include gift cards. Legal wrangling over the law, with a lawsuit involving AmEx, resulted in the striking down of many requirements of the law, but the ZIP code collection mandate remains.
Brooks Smith, President and Chief Executive Officer at InComm, said the law left the distributor "no option other than to cease selling InComm products in the state." Talbott Roche, President of Blackhawk Network, said the distributor and its retail partners could not comply with the law because they have no "cost-effective way to record data from gift card purchasers or their ultimate gift recipients."
Legislation is working its way through the New Jersey legislature to repeal the gift card provisions of the law. In March 2012, the New Jersey Assembly passed a bill that would remove certain types of stored-value (gift) cards from the list of instruments covered under the law.
A1871, sponsored by Democratic assemblymen Patrick J. Diegnan Jr., Paul D. Moriarty and Gordon M. Johnson, would not only remove gift cards from the ranks of escheatable property, but eliminate any gift cards sold in New Jersey from having expiration dates, thus allowing cardholders access to gift card funds into perpetuity.
Diegnan said the updated law has caused "a significant amount of uncertainty for consumers and businesses alike," while Moriarty characterized the bill as restoring "sanity to the system" and protecting consumers' rights to unclaimed property.
Setting an unsettling precedent
The 3,500 member New Jersey Retail Merchants Association, in tandem with AmEx and the New Jersey Food Council, sued New Jersey over the unclaimed property law. They argued, among other things, that the reporting requirements on gift card purchases stipulated by the law would be too time consuming and costly to implement, and would result in providers and retailers eliminating gift card programs in New Jersey.
John Holub, President of the NJRMA, said the law makes New Jersey "the most unfriendly state in the country for gift cards," and added, "It's not only anti-business, it's anti-consumer at the same time."
Holub said the New Jersey law was solely a revenue generating initiative for the state. He fears the law, if it stands, will set a precedent for other state governments to follow. "Other states are still struggling with their budgets," he said. "And we certainly don't want anyone else to think this is a good idea and one where they can potentially raise some money."
Holub is optimistic New Jersey can repeal the gift card provisions of the law. He anticipates a companion bill to the Assembly bill will be introduced in the New Jersey Senate this May, when the legislature returns from a budget break.
In the meantime, the NJRMA is in ongoing discussions with the administration of New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie to arrive at a solution. "We're hopeful this is going to be resolved sooner than May," Holub said.
For additional news stories, please visit www.greensheet.com and click on "Read the Entire Story" in the center column below the latest news story excerpt. This will take you to the full text of that story, followed by all other news stories posted online.
Notice to readers: These are archived articles. Contact names or information may be out of date. We regret any inconvenience.