The Green Sheet Online Edition
August 23, 2010 • Issue 10:08:02
Best not complain about innovation
In light of recent MLS Forum posts criticizing PayPal and Google Checkout, a recent article, "A New Wave for Payments?" published by David Randolph in Prairie Trails Software Inc.'s newsletter, A Consultant's View, bears consideration.
Randolph stated that "according to Warren Buffet, there are three I's in any business cycle: Innovators, Imitators and Idiots. One way to tell when the Idiots have taken over is when price is the only differentiator.
"When we see that, it is time to start watching for new innovation to happen in that business. The human dynamic is that the Idiots do so much harm to the customers that new Innovators see how to take those customers away."
I immediately thought of the Imitators and Idiots copying the bankcard/credit card model, unbundling pricing to make it appear cheaper when it really is more costly, but selling it on prices composed of smoke and mirrors.
The article went on to say that most innovation begins at the low end where established companies are unwilling to go and that in the payments industry the low end is small merchants who don't qualify for standard merchant accounts.
Randolph pointed out that while "the card processors have pushed NFC (and not gotten very far), PayPal had a million people download their iPhone application in [the] first three weeks after it was launched."
He also noted that merchant acceptance of PayPal is on the rise, and some traditional merchants who qualify for merchant accounts are opting to use PayPal instead.
"The challenge to the ISO community is that of relevance," Randolph added. "If the merchants can be served either by a low-cost 'commodity' provider or they can go to PayPal and not bother with a merchant service provider, why deal with an ISO?"
I propose that there are only a handful of Innovators in today's acquiring world, and some of those grousing about the service provided by alternative payment providers are my generation, baby boomers, and some immediate post-boomers.
Reflecting on one MLS Forum member's comment about being dissatisfied when phoning PayPal and other online entities for service, I concluded:
1. Calling customer service demonstrates a generational perspective - older generation.
2. Younger generations use online technology to obtain service when they need and want it. Otherwise, for them, it's disposable.
3. Expecting service, especially quick service, is also old generation.
4. The success of Wal-Mart Stores Inc. and Internet buying demonstrates that price above all else is more important than service. Wal-Mart has also conditioned the buying public to a lack of service or to self service.
Like it or not, service no longer exists, though boomers (my generation) expect service and are willing to pay a bit more for it. But we are a dying generation.
Thank you for sharing your thought-provoking perspective in response to excerpts from the GS Online MLS Forum thread "Why us over PayPal or Google Checkout," published in the Forum section of The Green Sheet, July 12, 2010, issue 10:07:01.
Those who want to read the entire thread, begun July 14, 2010, can do so online. Just register and log on at www.greensheet.com/forums/viewforum.php?f=1. To read "A New Wave for Payments?" in full, visit, www.prairietrail.com/newsletter/2010/Jul10.html.
Call us, write us
Would you like us to cover a particular topic? Is there someone you consider an industry leader? Did you like or dislike a recent article in The Green Sheet? What do you think of our latest GSQ? E-mail your comments and feedback to email@example.com or call us at 800-757-4441.
Notice to readers: These are archived articles. Contact names or information may be out of date. We regret any inconvenience.