GS Logo
The Green Sheet, Inc

Please Log in

A Thing
View Archives

View PDF of this issue

Care to Share?

Table of Contents

Lead Story

Transformation: Checks in the 21st century

Patti Murphy
The Takoma Group


Industry Update

Heartland files suit, claims processing scheme

Count down to ETA registration

Pay By Touch sued by employees

Global Discover-y

Black, cyber and green, shoppers appear keen

Alternative payments shake-up


Craig Thomson

Mobile tech and the ATM

Travis K. Kircher

Industry Leader

J. David Siembieda –
Man on the move


Counting our blessings

Paul Rasori

Small merchants mean big future

Jeff Fortney
Clearant LLC


Street SmartsSM:
Sale away, team

Dee Karawadra
Impact PaySystem

Office shopping done for you

Joel and Rachael Rydbeck
Nubrek Inc.

Make the most of your sales meeting

Maxwell Sinovoi
United Bank Card Inc.

Why use an executive recruiter?

Curt Hensley
CSH Consulting Inc.

B2B: Pedal to the floor

Aaron Bills
3Delta Systems Inc.

Company Profile

World Gift Card

New Products

High-tech data security in your wallet

Product: Emue Card
Company: Innovative Card Technologies and Emue Tec

Fast, photogenic PCI-compliant card reader

Product: Optimum L4150
Company: Hypercom Corp.


Open letter

E-mail for efficiency, phone for nuance

Get into the giving spirit





Resource Guide


A Bigger Thing

The Green Sheet Online Edition

December 10, 2007  •  Issue 07:12:01

previous next

Alternative payments shake-up

Tighter economic times are here, and retailers are looking to pinch pennies. One emerging solution is alternative payments such as PayPal, Google Checkout and Bill Me Later, which can help merchants slash their credit and debit card processing fees. However, this tactic could prove detrimental to those whose livelihoods rely on revenue from card processing fees.

PayPal acts like a middle man during transactions. Payments are withdrawn from the user's PayPal-linked credit card or bank account.

Google Checkout expedites checkout and payment by allowing consumers to store account details for their credit and signature-debit cards in an electronic wallet. Bill Me Later is an instant card service and attracts customers by acting as an open-ended credit card in online transactions.

These three have paved the way for companies such as TrialPay Inc. and Inc.

TrialPay is a conversion tool that allows customers to pay for one item by purchasing something else, in turn, giving them a discounted or free item. Webloyalty provides customers benefit packages, which then boost sales for e-commerce merchants.

Are credit cards losing ground to alternative payment services? According to Javelin Strategy & Research, this could be true: Alternative payment is not a niche trend; it is slowing credit card growth and contributing to the decline of cash and checks. Javelin's projected numbers also show a shift in consumer preference from traditional cards to alternative payment methods.

Mouse-clicking highs

Much of this switch has been driven by e-commerce. Javelin predicts online transactions will reach $355.2 billion over the next five years. By 2012, 30% of Americans will turn to alternative payments - stored-value, e-mail payments and instant credit - when purchasing online, up from 14% in 2007.

"Although it took nearly a decade for alternative payment methods to secure their position in the online world, it's apparent that everyday consumers are ready to view them as a trusted and viable way to buy online," said Bruce Cundiff, Senior Analyst with Javelin.

Some experts believe credit and debit cards paved the way for alternative payments. A Celent LLC study shows PayPal was still highly dependent on credit cards for account funding in 1999, with a 96% dollar volume for all consumer e-commerce purchases.

But fees exceeding 3% for card-not-present transactions sparked merchants to provide new value propositions. Celent's study shows just 12% of 2005 online payment volume was attributable to alternative payment options. However, it projects the total will more than double by 2009 to 26%, dropping online card volume to 50%.

According to Cundiff, PayPal is the main reason credit and debit card alternatives have gained a roughly 14% market share. PayPal said it has more than 153 million accounts worldwide and is available in 190 world markets in 17 different currencies.

Online today, offline tomorrow

And the expected growth in alternative payments may not be limited to e-commerce. "Given the recent online surge, we expect to see some of these trends transfer to offline buying over time," Cundiff said. "For example, more consumers may prefer to use alternative payment methods instead of credit cards, online and in person. But overall, we see continuing growth of online transaction and a decline of paper payment methods."

Force field formation

But not everything is rosy in the alternative payments market. Challenging the PayPals of the world is the surge of e-commerce fraud. A CyberSource Corp. survey estimates online fraud losses will grow to $3.6 billion in 2007, up from $3.1 billion in 2006.

"Merchants did see their online sales grow approximately 20%, but the costs of managing fraud grew a nearly identical amount," said Doug Schwegman, Director of Customer and Market Intelligence for CyberSource. "The picture is one of merchants swimming harder against an accelerating current."

In response, merchants are adding more antifraud tools, such as velocity monitoring, to their e-commerce systems. In 2007, 53% of merchants used five or more fraud detection tools. The largest merchants used an average of eight.

One outcome of adding fraud detection tools is that more orders may be diverted for manual review. CyberSource estimates that approximately 38% more orders were reviewed in 2007 than in 2006, and that extra diligence may have cost merchants an additional $100 million.

As the appeal for alternative payments continues to climb, merchants will find ways to combat fraud and offer as many payment options to consumers as possible. For now the alternative payments sphere is playing catch-up to credit and debit cards, but will it become the front-runner in time?

Notice to readers: These are archived articles. Contact names or information may be out of date. We regret any inconvenience.

previous next

Spotlight Innovators:

North American Bancard | Simpay | USAePay | Impact Paysystems | Board Studios