The Green Sheet Online Edition
June 23, 2025 • 25:06:02
Capital One + Discover: A radical rewiring of revenue
When Capital One announced its $35.3 billion acquisition of Discover, headlines focused on scale. But beneath the surface lies a strategic masterpiece: one of the most ambitious revenue reallocation plays in modern banking history.This isn't merely growth, it's a complete rewiring of transaction money flows. Capital One is redirecting billions away from payment networks directly into its own ecosystem.
The old model: Shared control, split revenue
Under the traditional open-loop setup, Capital One issued cards, but the infrastructure was owned by Visa and Mastercard. Verifi (Visa) and Ethoca (Mastercard) handled chargeback alerts, raking in fees every time a dispute triggered. Every swipe split revenue: a portion to Capital One, a chunk to the networks, and fees to the dispute platforms.
The new model: Close the loop, keep the margin
By acquiring Discover, Capital One gains a full-stack payments loop. This changes everything. Now Capital One can avoid paying network fees (usually 0.13 to 0.15 percent per transaction); own the interchange, keeping the full approximate 1.5 percent; bypass Verifi and Ethoca, removing $20 (estimated) alert fees on every chargeback; and monetize transaction data directly, opening new revenue streams such as analytics, loyalty and risk pricing.
Revenue reclamation, measured in billions
Even a modest 10 percent migration of Capital One's card volume to Discover's network delivers substantial returns, assuming the following:
- Capital One 2024 purchase volume: $272.6 billion
- Average order value: $160.90
- Chargeback rate: 1 percent
- Verifi/Ethoca alert fee per dispute: $20
- Interchange fee: approximately 1.5 percent per transaction
If just 10 percent of Capital One’s 2024 card volume is routed through Discover’s network, the revenue breakdown with a 10 percent margin is:
- Interchange margin (1.5 percent): $408.9 million
- Network fee savings (0.13 percent): $35.4 million
- Dispute alert fees (1.69 million alerts at $20): $33.9 million
- Total annual gain: about $478 million
That’s nearly half a billion dollars per year from redirecting a fraction of transactions. If Capital One shifts its entire $272.6 billion card volume to Discover's network, here's the revenue breakdown:
- Interchange margin (1.5 percent): $4.089 billion
- Network fee savings (0.13 percent): $354 million
- Chargeback alert fees (16.9M alerts at $20): $338.6 million
- Total annual gain: approximately $4.78 billion
That’s nearly $5 billion per year that previously lined the pockets of Visa and Mastercard, now consolidated under Capital One’s control.
Could Capital One become the next Visa?
If Capital One opens up Discover’s network to external issuers—Chase, Citi or even Chime—it could transform from a card issuer into a card network as a platform. If it acquires 10 percent of total U.S. credit card purchase volume (about $10 trillion in 2024) from other issuers, $1 trillion would be routed through Discover rails.
The U.S. card network opportunity (10 percent external issuer adoption) would result in retained interchange margin of 1.5 percent, or $15 billion; earned network fees of 0.13 percent, or $1.3 billion; and chargeback tooling, data monetization, loyalty and lending margins from $1 billion to $3 billion. The total potential annual revenue would be $17 billion to $19.3 billion from enabling other banks to issue on Discover's rails.
There are several other downstream effects—from transaction-level incentives to fraud tooling to the fees tied to every dispute or refund. Each of these layers, previously controlled by external platforms and networks, now represent potential margin upside or cost efficiency under Capital One’s roof. The real strategic value extends well beyond these headline numbers.
Why this matters
As merchants, issuers and regulators grow weary of Visa and Mastercard's duopoly tax, Capital One’s play isn’t just disruptive—it’s timely. This isn’t just about scale. It’s about financial architecture, about who owns the rails and who profits from the friction.
The foundation is being laid for a bank-powered network renaissance, where value creation is no longer diluted across fragmented players. It sets a precedent not just for banks but for anyone in the fintech, BNPL or embedded payments space. Watch for product launches, partner announcements and merchant adoption signals. If even a few dominoes fall, Capital One’s closed loop could quietly become the most lucrative open secret in payments. 
Payments innovator and chargebacks expert Tarun Singh, leads Product at Disputed, has built products that scale, driven multimillion-dollar growth and created solutions now used by 10,000+ merchants. Contact him at Tarun@disputed.ai.
Notice to readers: These are archived articles. Contact information, links and other details may be out of date. We regret any inconvenience.
