GS Logo
The Green Sheet, Inc

Please Log in

A Thing
View Archives

View PDF of this issue

Care to Share?

Table of Contents

Lead Story

Will smart phones drive out plastic cards?


Industry Update

VeriFone expands mobile payment footprint

Is Cimbal's proximity payment network a game changer?

IDC's take on mobile payment schemes


Eight payment companies listed on Inc. 500

Selling Prepaid

Prepaid in brief

Suit the gift card to the merchant

Thom Aldredge
World Gift Card


Cash still standing its ground

Patti Murphy
The Takoma Group

Further fraud trends in 2010

Nicholas Cucci
Network Merchants Inc.


Street SmartsSM:
Are mobile payments a threat to ISOs? - Part 1

Ken Musante
Eureka Payments LLC

The power of word of mouth

Nancy Drexler
Marketing Consultant

Who's your counterparty?

Barry Sloane
Newtek Business Services Inc.

Four things to know about security interests

Sarah Weston
Jaffe, Raitt, Heuer & Weiss PC

Command performance meetings

Dale S. Laszig
Castles Technology Co. Ltd.

Company Profile

Blackhawk Network

New Products

Easy inventory management

eProcessing Network LLC


If you're in business, you need a plan



Resource Guide


A Bigger Thing

The Green Sheet Online Edition

September 27, 2010  •  Issue 10:09:02

previous next

Is Cimbal's proximity payment network a game changer?

A software-based proximity payment offering that uses two-dimensional bar codes as payment drivers has reignited discussion about alternative POS payments.

The service, an offering of Calif.-based software firm Cimbal Inc., was introduced Aug. 31, 2010, for person-to-person (P2P) payments. The service is available on the Apple Inc. iPhone and will soon be made available on Google Inc.'s Android operating system and Research in Motion Ltd.'s BlackBerry devices, according to Florian Brody, Vice President of Marketing for Cimbal. He also said consumer-to-merchant payments with Cimbal would be available in the coming months.

The service requires that merchants and customers register their respective bank account data with Cimbal. To conduct a payment, the payee creates a two-dimensional bar code on a smart phone or POS system; the payer then accesses the system by entering a glos PIN code, and uses his or her phone's high-resolution camera to capture the bar code, at which time the transaction is authenticated through Cimbal's back-end payment network.

"We collect the bank account information," Brody said. "Then the customer goes to the store, and the merchant presents the code. You open the application; there is a PIN; then you just hold the phone and phone camera to the code; it makes a 'bing' and you're done."

According to Brody, the service helps protect payment information by keeping it out of every transaction. The bar code created by the payee "refers to the payment transaction with no personal information in the code," he said. Instead, the processing of payment information and subsequent transfer of funds from one bank account to another is conducted through Cimbal's back-end network, in conjunction with the automated clearing house (ACH) network.

"The code itself is completely useless and expires; it is a one-time code," Brody said.

Trying to break the stalemate

Cimbal is not technically a near field communication (NFC) payment product because it does not use radio frequency transmissions to convey payment information, although it does function in a similar way by allowing consumers to make quick POS payments using a cell phone and without having to key in numbers.

While NFC and other proximity payment products have waited for years in the offing in the United States, Cimbal has the potential to break that stalemate because it is more easily integrated than conventional NFC offerings, Brody said. While most NFC products require that merchants obtain new hardware for their POS systems, Cimbal requires only a quick POS software upgrade, he said. Cimbal also allows two consumers to make P2P payments if they both have smart phones, a function not allowed by some NFC networks.

Brody added that Cimbal will offer merchants the same marketing advantages touted by NFC providers - namely that they will be able to market to consumers by targeting the same device (a customer's phone) used to make payments. He said that the system, by bypassing the use of an intermediate payment device like a credit card, will be able to charge merchants "about half" of their customary interchange rate for transactions.

"For merchants, the opportunity to integrate everything from loyalty programs to specialty coupons to benefits to additional features creates a very interesting additional incentive," he said

Industry observers who have watched proximity payments struggle to take off over the years are more skeptical about Cimbal's prospects. Adil Moussa, Analyst at Aite Group LLC, said that, while the product would be easier for merchants to integrate, it may lack the incentive to spur widespread consumer adoption.

"It's premature to say if this is going to work or not," he said. "Looking at what has happened so far, every development [with proximity payments] has faced a gigantic barrier of entry. This has going for it the P2P offering and the linking to the ACH system... but they're touting the 'wow' factor as the first selling point, that it's really cool, but cool itself doesn't sell, especially in the payments world.

"What is my incentive as a consumer to do this?" he added. "That's really what most people forget. What value are you bringing to the consumer besides the 'wow' factor that I can pay with my phone? I don't see anything else, quite honestly."

Notice to readers: These are archived articles. Contact names or information may be out of date. We regret any inconvenience.

previous next

Spotlight Innovators:

North American Bancard | Simpay | USAePay | Impact Paysystems | Board Studios